PreS-Gr 3–Simple text and beautiful illustrations pack a strong emotional punch in this picture book. Based on the author’s own memories of being the child of Chinese immigrants in Ohio, the story follows a young girl who is in the car with her family. They spot watercress growing in a ditch and stop to collect it for their dinner later. The girl refuses to eat it, embarrassed of how they got their food, as well as their used furniture and clothes, believing that “Free is bad.” Her parents don’t understand her humiliation as she doesn’t understand their excitement over the meal. Words are used sparingly; the illustrations complete all that is left unsaid. The most poignant spread is when the girl’s mother tells them about their uncle and how there was never enough to eat. On one page, her little brother holds up his empty bowl; on the next, his seat is empty. Readers of various ages will want to discuss the layers of miscommunication between cultures and between generations, and how to be more mindful of others’ experiences. But the work is far more than a lesson. A tightly woven piece of story and watercolor art is exemplified in one spread, where the the cornfields of Ohio become the famine-stricken land of China.
VERDICT A powerful story sure to awaken empathy and curiosity: Who else left behind a homeland, and at what cost?
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!