J vs. K

Gr 2-5–Two fifth graders are ready to go head-to-head in the annual storytelling competition. One is renowned for his drawing skills and one for his writing. When their rivalry reaches a breaking point, they realize that they can work better together. This is a hybrid graphic novel/chapter book by Newbery Award–winning authors Alexander and Craft, and their talent shines through on every page. Both the authors are as much characters as the kids they’ve created to represent fictionalized younger versions of themselves. Interspersed throughout are writing tips, drawing advice, and story-crafting lessons. These asides turn a book about creating stories into a master class; but the asides and intertextual commentary are so humorous that young readers may not realize just how much they are learning. The black-and-white drawings are wonderfully done; simple but full of humor and character. Each element of design, including the different fonts for the author commentary, adds to the impact of this unique novel, making it very appealing for both fans of graphic novels and prose. Elementary children will come for the humor and great illustrations, but their teachers and families will appreciate the positive messaging and embedded storytelling tips.