K-Gr 2—Abby's parents have always said no to a family pet-but what about a class pet? A temporary pet. A compromise. It comes home for a day or two and then returns to school. Once Abby convinces her parents, she finds it even harder to convince her teacher, who insists that caring for a duck (yes, a class duck named Max) is no easy task. Ducks have certain demands and only children in the proper environment may take them home. Abby works tirelessly for hours to make things just right-and to be sure she beats her weird neighbor Noah to the punch. With much persistence and determination she is finally allowed to take Max home. But then, after all that, she loses him. During the search for him, an unexpected friendship forms between Abby and Noah. Winning pencil drawings enliven and add humor to this simple story. Unfortunately, the characters are not developed well enough to create a foreseeable following. An additional purchase suitable for those looking to expand their short-chapter-book collections for emerging readers.—Karinn Figdore, William Penn Charter School, Philadelphia, PA
Pet-deprived Abby longs to take the class pet, a duck, home overnight. The satisfying plot includes a well-deserved visit to Abby's house and an exciting chase after the duck escapes. Humorous, suspenseful, and heartfelt, the story also manages to be insightful. Frequent illustrations enhance the humor, help propel the action, and even occasionally add to characterization in this tale aimed at second graders.
Duck for a Day is a fresh take on a perennially appealing topic -- the class pet. Here, said class pet is a duck named Max, and pet-deprived Abby longs to earn the privilege of taking him home overnight. Active and involving right from the first ("Abby leaned forward and stared. The new teacher’s bag was moving"), the plot unfolds satisfactorily to include a contest to build Max the ideal "aquatic environment," a well-deserved visit to Abby’s house, and an exciting chase to find Max after he escapes from her backyard. By turns humorous, suspenseful, and heartfelt, the story also manages to be insightful (into the nature of friendship, for example, as Abby comes to like her odd classmate and next-door neighbor Noah through their shared devotion to Max). Author McKinlay uses language that is inventive but not beyond the abilities of the book’s intended second-grade audience. When Max first sits on Abby’s feet during art, for instance, she stays perfectly still: "She liked the way her feet felt all soft and warm with feathery breathing." Appropriately for its audience, this early chapter book features an open and accessible layout, with frequent pencil illustrations that enhance the humor, help propel the action, and even occasionally add to characterization. Max may be a temporary visitor, but new readers will want to take Duck for a Day home on a more permanent basis. martha v parravano
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!