PreS-Gr 2–“Fish don’t belong in trees,” point out friends Bird and Cat, reasonably. But Mr. Fish has a solid explanation for his presence, and he is staying put; when Cat observes, “Fish can’t live out of water. They can’t breathe,” and Bird asks, “How are you even alive right now?” Mr. Fish simply obtains a “roly bowl” (“for the fish on the go”). Mr. Fish’s loudness and rudeness drive Bird and Cat away. But when he tries to host a party for other fish, it’s a flop. After some soul searching, Mr. Fish apologizes to Bird and Cat and asks for their help making the tree a pleasant and livable place for all. A deliberately static setting and flat perspectives encourage readers to notice changes from one page turn to the next, and there are many humorous touches from beginning to end (“fin”).
VERDICT Whimsical, quirky, and unpredictable enough to keep kids and adults alike on their toes, this is a winner for story times or one-on-one—an all-around charming addition to picture book collections.
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!