16 Forever

Gr 9 Up–Carter Cohen is perpetually stuck reliving his 16th year, losing all memories and physical changes every time he is about to turn seventeen. Rubin dives headfirst into the hilarity and horror of Carter’s unique situation of navigating high school and relationships without memory of the previous experience. While the time loop is a much-used trope, its exploration from the point of view and voice of Carter is unique, lending a fresh perspective to the familiar concept. The writing is fluid and fun, with plenty of humor. Rubin successfully captures the tension between Carter’s desire to unstick and the tragic necessity of time and memory for love and connection. This complexity is most evident in his relationship with Maggie Spear, the girl he loved in his last loop who must endure the pain of starting over. Even when the repetitive nature of the story starts to drag, Carter’s sharp wit keeps the narrative engaging. The novel successfully asks what it means to grow up when one is eternally locked at 16. Its blend of fantasy, trauma, and sarcastic humor with romance, despite the occasionally repetitive plot moments, makes it a compelling read for young adult audiences. Carter is white, Maggie is presumed white, and Carter’s best friend is Asian American.