Bateman plays with the frightening horror tropes of isolation and creepy old cabins but gives them a child-friendly spin in the end. Recommended for anyone who wants an eerie tale with a cheery ending.
The production is nicely presented, but seems aimed at an adult audience who would better appreciate the situation. Still, teen animators might find this a useful example for storyboarding and creating their own productions.Teresa Bateman, Brigadoon Elementary, Federal Way, WA
These Caldecott classics, whether shown individually or independently, should find a home in most elementary school collections, thanks to their memorable art and appealing narratives.—Anne Bozievich, Friendship Elementary School, Glen Rock, PA
This extraordinary, fascinating look into a little-known historical event has multiple curriculum connections, from history to art. It would be a valuable addition to any collection and inspire viewers to do further research.