Gr 2–4—This beginning reader introduces
Anne Frank as she admires the chestnut tree that stands outside the window of the Secret Annex. The next statement instantly catches readers' attention: "she had not been outside for 597 days." Observing it helped her keep track of the passing seasons and calm her emotions. The changes wrought by the Holocaust are described in terms a child can understand: Anne cannot go swimming, is not allowed to go to movies, and must change schools. However, due to the book's controlled vocabulary, some concepts are oversimplified; for example, the term concentration camp is used but not defined, though "Anne's parents knew that when Jews were sent away, they were never heard from again." Readers are told that "Anne did not survive the war. But her diary did." They also learn that the chestnut tree no longer stands, but that seedlings from it have been planted all over the world. Like Anne, its legacy continues. The somber colors in Sayles's paintings contribute to the serious tone and historical feel of the story. Students in need of more more context can read Josephine Poole's Anne Frank (Knopf, 2005), which is at a higher reading level.—
Jackie Partch, Multnomah County Library, Portland, OROne sentence in Anne Frank's diary reads: "I firmly believe that nature can bring comfort to all who suffer." Nature, as represented by a chestnut tree outside an attic window in the Secret Annex, serves as a continuing image for this beginning chapter book. Here, Anne's story begins with her in hiding, then flashes back to her early childhood, the Nazi takeover of Holland, the persecution of the Jews, the Franks' decision to disappear, their daily routine in the Annex, and their eventual capture. The presence of the tree throughout Anne's life in hiding not only gives her a sense of peace but also provides young readers a respite from her ordeal. Her death is described gently: "Anne did not survive the war." Illustrations are dark and somber except those depicting Anne's pre-war life or Annex visits from helpers bringing food and books. When she flees to the attic for a glimpse of her chestnut tree, a bright yellow light creates a path to the soothing power of nature, while the moon's white light shines through the window. Anne's story comes full circle when, after the chestnut tree is blown down in a storm in 2010, its fruit is used to plant other trees, "inspiring people to see the world as Anne did." Signaling a change in the narrative, a photograph of the Anne Frank House introduces an author's note. More sophisticated recommended readings (on the copyright page) and a website (AnneFrank.org) complete this abbreviated biography. betty carter
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!